Best Bait for Crappie Fishing

If you wish to take on fish like crappies who are all-time big meat eaters then you must tempt them with their favorite platter. That’s probably the only way you can step up and have a good shot of catching more fish.

Knowing the value of a lure, anglers earlier used to pull out minnows and shrimp from their kit to tempt crappies before getting them hooked. But these days people are more inclined towards artificial bait as it prevents the strain of finding a natural diet and amplifies the possibility of getting more crappies.

Also, it came about that the fish were really falling into the artificial bait which caused a feeding frenzy. The attractive color of the bait with precise movement and vibration had an irresistible urge on fishes like crappies and panfish.

As far as fishing bait is concerned, there are unprecedented options available to choose from including feathered jigs and rooster tail spinner. But we’ve especially got you the list of the best bait for crappie fishing.

They may look like kid stuff from far and near but the work this bait does is nothing to be compared. These pocket-sized fishing lures have proven to be really great in fishing crappies as well as panfish.

After a lot of research, we’ve got you some of the best bait for crappie fishing in the market which is far easy to set-up and can be arranged in different ways.

Best Bait for Crappie Fishing – Top List

1. Berkley PowerBait Freshwater Fishing Bait

Berkley PowerBait Fresh Water Fishing Bait


Ready to dunk your most reliable gear inside the freshwater and catch some giants then let’s crank with Berkley PowerBait Freshwater Fishing Bait.

A look alike of minnow, Berkley’s powerbait are smartly designed to impersonate the action of a fleeing baitfish while the split tails encourage the real one to have a big bite of it.

Although made with an aromatized tough PVC plastic, they act more like a dead lure, enticing the fish the whole time. And since they taste so good like live worms, the fishes clench onto the hook 18 times longer than any other soft plastic bait.

Meanwhile, to brush-up the flavors and make it work, it took more than 25 years for the scientist of Berkley’s. They are so adaptable that anglers can use it from shallow water to open and catch biggies like muskie, walleye, and trout. This fishing lure is also great for spinner rigs, drop shots and jig trailers.

2. PowerBait FreshWater Fishing Bait (All Power Bait Styles) – Berkley

PowerBait FreshWater Fishing Bait (All Power Bait Styles) - Berkley


If you’re seeking a great value for a price in a fishing lure then look no further than Berkley’s PowerBait Freshwater Fishing Bait. The beauty of this fishing bait is its ability to tempt hungry crappies and trap them to the hook.

Although not the prettiest of all baits, they can easily fool you for a real mice tail leaving out the graphic chartreuse fluor orange color. Similar to the other series of Berkley PowerBait, floating mice tail too take off the motion of baitfish and employ it to invite big crappie for lunch.

Everytime you toss this jig into water, it unfurls a sweet scent which drives the fish insane bringing them all the way to the hook. Likewise, it’s so impressive with rushing through the water and making its own path to reach up to its predator.

3. Stoll’r Crappie Baits – Sportsman Supply Inc. Bobby Garland

Stoll’r Crappie Baits - Sportsman Supply Inc. Bobby Garland


It may look like a gummy fish at the first glance but Stoll’r bait for Crappie fishing from Bobby Garland is actually an exquisite fishing lure with the glittery color combo of electric chicken.

It is molded from a soft plastic which allows the bait to wander frivolously and at long last bring the fish near the hook. The three-dimensional body formation of Stoll’r with a flat head at front section and bulky tail makes it look like an authentic sperm whale.

This bait for Crappie fishing seems to operate the fish and read the mind of its predator, making the first move to hoax it and get it hooked. The tail of the bait produces vibration at every range of motion and speed which fish can easily feel.

To get more yields in a high volume water, you might want to rig out the bait to a rooster tail jig of a size varying from 1/16 to 1/8 as it increases the rate of its sink and fish more crappies. It’s incredible spinning action caused by a silver or brass blade covers the hook and transmits an alluring quiver.

All models of Stoll’r crappie bait are 2.5 inches long and are available in 8 different patterns from black hot pink to silver white. On each pack of Bobby Garland, you’ll get 12 pieces of durable Stoll’r crappie baits.

4. Baby Shad Crappie Baits – Sportsman Supply Inc. Bobby Garland

Baby Shad Crappie Baits - Sportsman Supply Inc. Bobby Garland


If any fishing bait has created fuss amidst anglers with its value and performance then it’s Bobby Garland’s Baby Shad Crappie Baits. In no time, it has created a global fandom with its smooth action and prowess to induce crappies.

It’s always tough to come up with unconventional design and Bobby Garland has done it with Shad. The fishing bait has a soft stout body with a delicate tail which delivers quick action after darting in the water. It is one of the best bait for Crappie fishing.

The two color contrast with a silver sparkle forms a visual display which emphasizes the whirling action of the tail and persuades the predator. It suits pretty much every water condition and offers quick fishing action even at a slow pace.

There are 18 Baby Shad Crappie Bait in each packet of Bobby Garland. Furthermore, you can find it in 7 different shades with glitter from head to tail which allows the bait to glow in dark water.

5. Mr. Crappie Grub Bait – Strike King

Mr. Crappie Grub Bait - Strike King


Strike King’s Mr. Crappie Grub bait for Crappie fishing is the current hot ticket for tempting crappies almost everywhere from shallow cover to freshwater. Evinced as one of the most innovative and finest products from Strike King till date, Grub is created out of a high-quality soft plastic.

It is designed to look crafty with the upper body of the bait transpiring as a worm while the tail is shaped wavy to produce quick action. Meanwhile, the single hook is pretty much good to hold the bait but you can outfit it with a jig head to get even better yields.

The 25 years of experience and attempt of Willow in making the finest fishing lure has definitely paid off as Grub has been a trustworthy companion while fishing crappies.

It does such an incredible job in causing hysteria among huge slab crappies and evoking them to feed on the mushy lure. You can get the Grub in as many as five colors including pumpkinseed chartreuse and tuxedo black laminate and all of it weighs no more than 0.2 ounces.

Similar articles you may like:

6. Shadalicious Swimbait – Strike King

Shadalicious Swimbait - Strike King


Anglers have once again found a reason to be delightful and this time with Strike King’s Shadalicious Swimbait. This bait for Crappie fishing is a go-to lure for those who opts to casts rather than trolling.

From its naturalistic design to quick movement and action, everything about the bait is incredible. It is molded from a soft plastic with an appealing look and lifelike colors to lure big fish and crappies.

The plunging action of the bait is really good as it can easily make its way to the crappies. You can peg it on an overweight hook or simply use it with a jig head to get a better yield but make sure you retrieve steadily.

Shadalicious Swimbait is found in wide-ranging colors from Citrus Shad to Green Gizzard and Neon Ghost Minnow. Apart from colors, there are different sizes of it lining up from 3.5 to 6.5 inches and you can choose it based on the size of your hook.

7. Slab Slay’r Crappie Baits – Sportsman Supply Inc. Bobby Garland

Slab Slay’r Crappie Baits - Sportsman Supply Inc. Bobby Garland


There’s no way you can ever come up with as incredible fishing bait as Bobby Garland Slab Slay’r Crappie Baits for a budget-friendly price. With Slab Slay’r, Bobby has epitomized what innovation really looks like and how extravagant a small fishing gear can be.

From the eye-catching design to the electric chicken color combination and functioning, everything about this bait is too grand to deal with. If anything has most contributed to the success of the bait then it’s the crafty look of Slay’r which has a ribbed but stiff body while the tail is narrow and spear-styled.

Another quality of this fishing bait is its skill to romp conscientiously and attract crappies to the limit by optimizing the maximum fishing action. This sheeny fishing bait is also popular among anglers to catch panfish.

8. Strike King Mr. Crappie Joker Bait

Strike King Mr. Crappie Joker Bait


If only aesthetics was the property then Strike King Mr. Crappie Jokers would have won all the fishing baits by a mile. One of the most modish artificial lures, Crappie is built strong with quality material components. This bait for Crappie fishing is is liked by the many fisherman.

Unlike the typical worm-styled bait, Mr. Crappie has a unique design with the back end looking like a joker hat. Strike King has kept the upper body of the bait firm and steady while the three piece tail wobbly aiming to provoke crappies.

The eye popping chartreuse pink color the bait seems to grab the attention of fish as it can catch everything from parish to bass and catfish.

It is equipped with a system control which serves the anglers with a perfect lure until it doesn’t dispel their doubts. Every packet of Strike King comes with 15 Joker baits, each of which is 2-inch long.

9. Mr. Crappie Thunder Bait – Strike King

Mr. Crappie Thunder Bait - Strike King


You can jig it, troll it, rip it, or just cast and Thunder bait will still manage to get you crappies to the maximal. This new line of fishing lure from Strike King is totally different from the earlier ones whilst the material used is as good as any other models.

It is designed with a stiff coil tube shaped body and a tail that flutters at 90 degrees to create shock waves in the water and persuade crappies. The body of the fishing lure is well-built and kept bulky on the far end so that it can easily come into the notice of freshwater fishes such as panfish and crappies.

There’s almost a dozen of multi-color Thunder bait available in the market so you’ve countless options to choose from. Irrespective of everything, you can choose the bait based on what type of water you’re fishing in.

10. Berkley Gulp Alive Minnow Soft Bait

 Berkley Gulp Alive Minnow Soft Bait


When the best angler meets the best fishing bait, nothing can stop them from hunting giants. And in that matter, the latest version of Gulp Alive Minnow Soft Bait is the supreme of all, leaving all the previous Gulps behind.

It makes an incredible artificial fishing lure having formed with high quality materials which are durable and smooth in action. Already they used to look like live minnows and now they even taste like one that Gulp Alive can effortlessly fill-in this small freshwater fish.

The fishing bait has a realistic exposition with captivating odour which can compel the crappies to fall in trap. In contrast to the plastic bait, it can dilate the power of the scent 400 times more and instigate fish from far and away.

Each Gulp Alive has a length measured 1-inch and a weight of 2.1 ounces. There are 4 colors of it available in the store and you can pick from either but take a consideration of what water type you’re into.

11. Baby Shad Crappie Baits – Bobby Garland

Baby Shad Crappie Baits - Bobby Garland


Forging a top-of-the-line artificial bait, Bobby Garland has ruled the roost for several years. It has provided anglers with some of the great quality fishing lures that are unbeatable both in appearance and action.

Baby Shad, being no unusual, offers exceptional features through its tiny stiff body. This 2-inch blue ice-silver bait is crafted from a soft plastic with Mo Glo design, causing it to gleam when exposed to low light.

It also creates its own silhouette to improve visibility in the water restricted from light. The body of the fishing bait is plump while the tail is spear-shared and transports a dancing action to seek attention from crappies.

Visualized and formulated by Bobby Garland, Shad comes in 18 different shades with each of them 2 inches long.

12. Gulp! Alive! Minnow (Soft) Fishing Bait – Berkley

Gulp! Alive! Minnow (Soft) Fishing Bait - Berkley


Berkley’s fishing bait has been an indispensable apparatus to seasoned anglers for almost 3 decades. Designed to emit a powerful scent, Gulp is used to mislead the fish and hold them longer in the hook than any other baits.

More lately, the Gulp! Alive! Minnow has been doing the job on behalf of its predecessor, helping anglers catch huge fish. This new model Berkley’s bait is utilizing its action to the best of its ability and distract the crappies until they don’t fasten to hook.

Moreover, Gulp imitates a wounded baitfish as soon as it is tossed in the water. The soft plastic continues to pour out the scent as it sprints in the water trying to provoke fish.

It also flutters those split tails to create a movement in the water and draw attention. You can use Gulp! Alive! Minnow to catch varied species of fish from crappies to walleye and largemouth bass.

13. PowerBait Trout Fishing Bait – Berkley

PowerBait Trout Fishing Bait - Berkley


PowerBait Trout Fishing Bait might go down as one of the most efficient and dependable fishing lures in Berkley’s history. Designed using oil-based resin and PVC, Powerbait is soft and strong enough to last years.

Like every other Berkley’s bait, PowerBait too has a strong scent infused in its body which takes time to come to action unlike Gulp. And that’s simply because the oil prevents the scent from releasing from the bait until the fish doesn’t take its bite.

The perfume used in the bait has a scent and flavor of a live trout due to which fish lingers on the hook for a very long time. PowerBait Trout has been scientifically proven to exceed salmon eggs and other powerful baits.

It comes in a container with wide-ranging flavors from cheese to fluorescent orange and Salmon Peach.

Factors to be considered while buying bait for crappie fishing

1. Right Color

The best asset of artificial bait is that it comes in different colors which are willing to fit in every water type. So, before purchasing a fishing bait for crappie, it’s important that you choose the right color jig which sees more likelihood of catching fish.

Instead of picking a random color fishing bait, it’s better to know the condition and depth of the water before taking up fishing. In that case, you’ll be in need of a bright and sparkly colored lure for murky and dingy water so that they can transpire themselves to the fish.

Similarly, if you’re turning to clear water for fishing, a realistic and matt color bait would work well.

2. Right Size

The size of a fishing bait is something you need to be very careful about before purchasing it. Usually it’s believed that a big bait will help catch large fish as they look more appetizing than the smaller ones.

In contrast to the belief, the smaller ones have also proven to be worthwhile and successful in catching giant fish like crappies. They are the simplest yet most effective fishing bait with great action and ability to paddle with the tail. The movement of a small size bait is accurate and they can also mimic live fish like trout and minnow and minnow.

3. Hooks

Hook is another tiny but most important gear while fishing crappies or any other fish. They are attached to the lure which then entice fish and trap them. For convenience, you can use a regular hook but for more yields, it’s good to use a jig head hook which provides the bait with a more natural look.

Final Verdict

It’s always tough to pick one best bait for crappie fishing out of a bunch of amazing lures. But if I had to make this one hard decision regardless of everything then it would be Berkley’s Powerbait Trout Fishing Bait.

Considered as one of the best lures to catch crappies, Powerbait has a great fragrance that draws fishes toward it. It also tastes great and produces a shimmering color which easily comes to the notice of fish.

You’ll have plenty to catch with Powerbait Trout Fishing bait as it’s also liked by panfish and minnows.

You may also like: